Beginning with some family oral history and family information, branches of my family tree have begun to sprout. Joining Ancestry.com enabled an in depth research of Federal Census records, cemetery records, death records and marriage records. Plus, other family trees posted on Ancestry.com provided previously unknown family information. These other trees have allowed tracing some of our heritage back through the American Colonies to the “Old World”. Tracing the family heritage is not yet complete; in fact it may never be completed due to lack of useable, reliable data. In essence, there are still missing branches, which are known to exist that have not sprouted.
How to describe the results of the research to date? A summary of my 4 families seems to be the best way to proceed. Comments will be included, so assumptions made in forming branches of the family tree can be better understood. Keeping this chapter manageable, meaningful and important family stories will not be included here and more details will be provided in later chapters.
Price Family
Based upon Federal Census Data for my Great-Grandfather Price, I believe to have found my Great-Great-Grandfather and Great-Great-Grandmother Price. What is this evidence that leads me to believe I’ve discovered these Great-Great-Grandparents? Family records show my Great-Grandfather’s (Robert S. Price) birthdate was 1845 in Kentucky, with several Federal Census Records confirming this birth year. In addition, these Federal Census Records list Kentucky as the birth state for his parents.
Using this datum, the 1850 Federal Census lists an R.S. Price (born 1816) with wife Theresa Price (born 1825) in Nelson County, Kentucky. Thomas (born 1843), Robert (Great-Grandfather Price?) (born 1845), Ann A. (born 1846) and Reason (born 1848) are listed as Price children. Both parents are listed as born in Kentucky. Since Robert’s birthdate matches both family and Federal Census Records, it seems a reasonable assumption that R.S and Theresa are my Great-Great-Grandparents. So far, further searches have not reveled R.S.Price’s first name, a marriage date or Theresa’s maiden name. Unfortunately, I could not check earlier Census Records because names are not provided, only the number of people in a given age bracket are given. At this time further research is required to determine if these assumption are correct and these unknowns answered.
However, the 1860 Federal Census has produced an anomaly. This record list a Ried Price (born 1826) listed with no wife and 7 Price children: Thomas (born 1843), Robert (born 1845), Ann (born 1847), Reason (born 1850), Elizabeth (born 1852). B. (born 1854) and Richd (Richard?) (born 1858). Obvious questions arise for this record. Is Ried the first name of R.S. Price in the 1850 Census? If so, there is a 10 year discrepancy in his birth date. If it is a new Price relative, who is he and what happened to R.S. and Theresa? While the birth dates for Thomas and Robert match the 1850 Census, those for Ann and Reason are different. Birth dates in Census records are always listed as “abt”, or about since the census worker asks for ages on the day of the census. Hence, these birth year could be off by one year. This fact may explain Ann’s difference in birth year, but Reason’s is off by 2 years, which may depend on who in the family gave the ages of everyone and their knowledge of everyone’s age. Finally, are Elizabeth, B. and Richd the children of R.S. and Theresa Price?
Without a doubt my Great-Grandfather was Robert S. Price born in Kentucky on 19 Nov 1845. The reason for this certainty is both family records and is confirmed in the 1920 Federal Census. Discovering the identity of my Great-Grandmother Price has been a real challenge. Two family records provide both a ? for her name while another lists a Susan Crow. These records give Apr 1908 as the date for Great-Grandmother Price’s death, whoever she is. All record searches have failed to discover a Susan Crow, much less one married to Robert S. Price. So, using the Census Records, other family trees and Price logic, possibly flawed, I believe Great-Grandmother Price was Mary Ann Price, nee Roberts born in Missouri, 25 Nov 1849. Robert S.Price and Mary Ann Roberts were married on 1 Oct 1868 in De Kalb County, Missouri.
How did I reach this conclusion? Well, Federal Census records for 1870, 1880 and 1900 lists an Robert S. and Mary A. Price family in Missouri and Kansas. These records list the following children: Sterling, born abt 1869 in Sherman, De Kalb Missouri, Nicholas born abt 1871 in Prairie, Wyandotte, Kansas, Anna M., born abt 1876 in Prairie, Wyandotte, Kansas, Alfred R. born abt 1882 in Prairie, Wyandotte, Kansas, and Lulu P. born abt 1887 in Shannon, Pottawattamie, Kansas. Okay, what makes me believe this is the correct Price family? First, the Federal Census for 1910 and 1920 show Prices I know first hand in Pottawattamie County, Kansas. These family members are my Grandfather and Grandmother Price, my Dad, my Uncle and my Aunt. I do not believe there would be more than one Robert S. Price in Pottawattamie County, Kansas in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Second, the 1910 Federal Census lists Robert S. Price living with Nicholas and Hallie A. Price family in Blue Valley, Pottawattamie, Kansas and R. S. is listed as widowed. Third, birthdate and birth state for Alfred R. Price matches those for my Grandfather Robert Alfred Price, plus the 1920 Federal Census listing him with his father, Robert S. Price in Orange, California. Finally, Mary A. Price and Lulu Pearl Price are buried in the Olsburg Cemetery in Pottawattamie, Kansas. Mary’s date of death is 19 Apr, 1908 with Lulu’s death on 6 Mar, 1908. Mary’s date of death matches the year given in my family records for an un-named Great-Grandmother. So, what happened to Robert S. Price?
Robert S. Price appears in 1920 Federal Census in Orange, Orange County, California. There is no record of when or why he moved to California. Adding to the mystery is that now he is listed as “divorced”. Who did he marry after Mary died? Where did he marry? Could it have been Susan Crow? I have no way of knowing since all searches for Susan Crow have revealed nothing. Robert S. Price died 8 Oct, 1927 in Orange, California. He is buried in the Fairhaven Memorial Park in Santa Ana, California. There is a photo of the cemetery and his headstone. Family records indicate he died due to heart problems.
Another confusing situation is that the various family trees I have reviewed cite the same Federal Census records I have encountered. Yet, these other trees vary considerably concerning Robert S. Price’s family. I believe these other trees contain their family data,or oral history, to augment the census records, which results in different family histories for Price family members. Another confusion exists as to the death of Mary A. Price. Her death is listed in Ancestry.om family trees in Kansas in 1905 and in Missouri in 1926. Even though these other family trees provide various Robert S. Price family histories, it is my belief I have made a valid interpretation of the Census Records and Mary A. Price’s cemetery information based on my own family knowledge.
While tracing the Price surname back in time has required considerable research along with some reasoned assumptions. To chronicle Price family history from this point forward further assumptions are not necessary because family history enters into my life’s memory. I know for a certainty my Grandfather and Grandmother Price were Robert Alfred Price and Charlotte (Lottie) Estelle Price, nee Huckstadt. Robert Alfred Price was born 23 Jun 1882 in Prairie, Wyandotte, Kansas, while Charlotte Estelle Huckstadt was born 23 Jul 1881 in Louisville, Kansas. They were married 14 Mar 1905, I assume Shannon, Pottawattamie, Kansas since both were residences of Shannon in 1900.
Robert and Lottie had 3 children: Walter Herman Price, born 5 Jul 1906 in Olsburg, Kansas, Robert Otto Price (my father), born 7 Apr 1909 in Westmoreland, Kansas and Gladys Mae Price, born 30 Jan 1911 in Westmoreland, Kansas. Both towns are in Pottawattamie County. Lottie died on 21 Feb 1911 in Westmoreland due to complications from Gladys’ birth. Grandmother Charlotte E. Price is buried in the Westmoreland Cemetery. While there is no photo of Robert and Lottie together, nor one of Robert, there are photos of Robert and the 3 children and one of Lottie. A date on the back of Grandmother Lottie’s photo indicates she was 23 at the time the photo was taken. While there is no date on the family photo, I suspect it is in 1912 based on the assumption that Gladys appears to be about 1+ years old. There is another photo of them in 1913 in which Gladys appears to have grown since this photo.
Walter, Gladys, Robert A. and Robert O. Price
Grandmother Charlotte “Lottie” Estelle Price
Sometime after Grandmother Lottie died Granddad Price moved to California. There is no record of when he moved, but it was prior to 1920. Granddad Price is listed in the 1920 Federal Census in Orange, California living with his father Robert S. Price. When Granddad left for California, Great-Grandmother Rosa Huckstadt raised the 3 Grandchildren. Eventually, all three children became permanent residents of California. Their travels to California is a multi-stage saga that is too involved to relate here. Reasons and adventures traveling to California will be described in a later chapter.
Grandfather Price married Opal Claire Stoves prior to 1930, since they are listed in the 1930 Federal Census as husband and wife. A daughter was born 8 Mar 1932 given the name Betty Lou Price. It is assumed that they were married in Orange, California. Thus, Walter, Robert and Gladys have a half sister. So, I guess that means I have a half-aunt and a Step-Grandmother Price, if these are the correct terminologies.
Robert Alfred Price committed suicide on 15 Dec 1935 in Orange, California. The reason for the suicide is a mystery and the only record in my possession is a letter from my Dad to Great-Grandmother Huckstadt informing her of his death. He is buried in Fairhaven Memorial Park, the same cemetery as Great-Grandfather Robert S. Price. There is a headstone photo, discovered on the internet.
Tracing the Price side of my family has taken its history back to 1816. Unfortunately, there are still some unknowns and anomalies in that history. What has been discovered is based, I believe, on reasonable logical assumptions. While further research is required to trace the family further back in time, this research will have to wait for a while. Stories of my immediate family will be the subject of the next chapter of Reflections.
Graham Family
History of the Graham family was a real mystery to me. Stories of the past were sparse and not really noteworthy or memorable. So, beyond knowing home was originally in Aledo, Illinois and some birthdays, knowledge of family history was very limited. After joining Ancestry.com the Graham branches began to sprout and leaf out. The primary reason was several other member trees that had been posted really began to pull back the black shroud on the family history. In fact, I was stunned to discover the following portrait posted with one of the family trees.
William Niblock Graham
A framed version of this portrait hung in my parent’s home as well as mine for as long as I can remember. Talk about knocking your socks off---WOW!! I knew it was my Great-Grandfather Graham, but did not have any clue as to his name. Now I could attach a name to my Great-Grandfather: William Niblock Graham!! Further research allowed the tracing of family history as well as forming this part of my family tree. As in the Price background I’ll start the Graham family background from the earliest years.
John Graham (Great-Great-Great-Grandfather) was born in 1773 somewhere in Ireland. John met Jane Niblock in Mercer County, Pennsylvania where they were married. Jane was also born in 1773 somewhere in Ireland. Whether they knew one another in Ireland is not known, nor when they arrived in America. Just think of the wild possibilities you can imagine with this information!! John and Jane had four children: Jane, born 9 Feb 1802, William Niblock (not my Great-Grandfather), born 15 Dec 1805, John P.(Great-Great-Grandfather), born 1807 and Elizabeth (or Mary). All children were born in Mercer County, Pennsylvania. It seems only John P. Graham married because no spouses have been uncovered for Jane, Elizabeth or William N. William died in 1819 in Mercer County, Pennsylvania at the age of 46. Jane lived until 1855 and died in Lawrence, Pennsylvania.
John P. Graham met and married Hannah Pearson, I suspect in Lawrence, Pennsylvania. Hannah’s family had roots in Pennsylvania from the mid-1700s. John and Hannah had 8 children: George Pearson (not my Grandfather), born 9 Dec 1832, Sarah Jane, born 1833, William Niblock (Great-Grandfather pictured above) born 15 Dec 1835, Harrison Pearson born 7 May 1837, Elizabeth M. born 10 Nov 1840, Richard Johnson born 1 Feb 1842, Ella or Ellen born in 1844 and Sadie born in 1854. All of them were born in Lawrence, Pennsylvania. Based on research to date all of the sons of John P. and Hannah Graham moved to Aledo, Mercer County, Illinois. I assume they moved from Pennsylvania to Illinois as part of the Western migration. It is interesting that all the Graham boys settled in Aledo, Illinois rather than different locales. At this time I have no record as to what happened to the Graham women, either a marriage or where they died. While William Niblock Graham is my Great-Grandfather, Harrison Pearson Graham (Great-Great-Uncle?) is also of interest to my family history through their sons and Grandchildren.
William Niblock Graham married Sarah Ann Paxton on 27 Jun 1861, probably in Aledo, Mercer County, Illinois. Sarah was born in 1844 in Mercer County, Illinois. William and Sarah had 5 children, probably all born in Aledo. The children were: John Paxton born in 1862, Eva L. born in 1864, Ralph born in 1866, Fancy or Fanny B. born in 1869 and George Pearson (my Grandfather) born 14 Sep 1871. Sarah Ann Graham, nee Paxton died 16 Jul 1873 in Aledo, Illinois. William Niblock Graham re-married Flora Ann Bassett on 23 Dec 1873. Boy, could you make up some story about this marriage being only 5 months after Sarah Ann died! William and Flora had 2 daughters: Islea S. born 23 Dec 1874 and Ethel Gertrude born 19 Apr 1880. Both Islea and Ethel were born in Aledo, Illinois. William died 16 Aug 1907 in Aledo and Flora died 24 Aug 1925 in Nilles, Berrien, Michigan.
My Grandfather, George Pearson Graham married my Grandmother Minnie A. Clifford in Aledo, Illinois in 1901 in Aledo, Illinois. Grandmother Minnie was born 8 Jun 1878 in Aledo, Illinois. My mother Pauline Gwendolyn Graham was born in Aledo on 27 Apr 1910 and was an only child. So, I have no Aunt or Uncle Graham. Grandfather George, Grandmother Minnie and Mother Pauline moved to Pomona, California and are recorded there in the 1920 Federal Census, finally settling in Santa Ana, California. As in the case of my Dad, Uncle Walter and Aunt Gladys, the final settling in Santa Ana will be related later.
Clifford Family
Although the Grandmother Clifford’s family was of extreme interest to me, I basically had no knowledge or information about her background. The extent of my knowledge was her family surname, where she was born and memories of staying with her and Granddad in Santa Ana. There is a faint recollection she died while I was very young. Then 3 years ago I received a letter from a Larry Hardesty in Nebraska inquiring whether I was the son of Robert and Pauline Price. Responding in the affirmative to his letter, I discovered that the Clifford family is also a branch in his family tree. Based on information from Larry and further searches on Ancestry.com has enabled me to learn about the Clifford family history.
To fully comprehend the history of the Clifford family it is necessary to begin with the Jones family in South Wales. Thus, the current day Prices have a definite Welsh connection. Issac and Ann Jones were both born in New Bridge, Wales early in the 19th Century. Issac was born 10 Dec 1814 and Ann was born 22 Dec 1814. They had 3 daughters born in New Bridge, Wales: Mary Ann born 10 May 1836, Gwen (Great-Grandmother Clifford) born 18 Apr 1838 and Elizabeth born abt 1840. The Jones family emigrated to America about 1841. After arriving in America they had an additional 6 children, for a total of 9! Interestingly, the first child born in America was born in either South Carolina or Georgia. The 1850 Census lists South Carolina, while the 1860 Census lists Georgia for the same child. The remaining 5 were born in Illinois, presumably in Aledo, Mercer County. There is no information when they moved from the South to Illinois.
Great-Grandmother Gwen Jones married Edward Clifford on 12 Mar 1862 in Mercer County, Illinois. Edward Clifford was born in County Alvin, Ireland about 1814. Great-Grandfather Edward and Great-Grandmother Gwen had 6 children: John Edward born abt 1863, Carl Issac born abt 1866, Harry born abt 1869, Burton E. born abt 1871, Minnie A. born 8 Jun 1878 and Roy H. born Oct 1874. All children were born in Mercer County, Illinois and presumably in the town of Aledo.
Spelling for Great-Grandmother Gwen varies in all the census records. The variations include Gwen, Guin, Guinn and I discovered a Gwendoline in one family tree. I tend to favor Gwen since Mom’s middle name is Gwendolyn. Gwen outlived Edward by about 30 years. Edward died 16 Mar 1886 at the age of 72, while Gwen died 27 Aug 1916. Both died in Mercer County and are buried in Mercer County’s Sugar Grove Cemetery. It has been reported that Gwen re-married, but so far there is no evidence to support this claim. In fact, I have a post card written by Burton to G. J. Clifford which was postmarked 1913. Since Gwen died in 1916, it seems doubtful she would have re-married at this age.
There is an obituary for Gwen I received from Larry Hardesty.
There is one very old photo of Great-Grandfather Edward Clifford. He has a very healthy set of sideburns!!
Edward Clifford
Huckstadt Family
Knowledge of the Huckstadt family history has been pretty much like the Cliffords. I knew about Great-Grandmother Rosa Huckstadt and heard the names of uncles and aunts that were mentioned, but since there was not a face to connect the name to, it was basically meaningless. Cousin Carol Pappas, nee Price gave me some Price/Huckstadt family information she had obtained from one of my Dad’s cousins, Louise. After a telephone conversation with Louise, she sent a high school report she composed after talking with Great-Grandmother Rosa Huckstadt. This paper provided information about Great-Grandmother Rosa Haid’s family. As it turns out the Huckstadt and Haid families are the genesis of our Germanic connection.
Great-Great-Grandfather Herman Von Sebastian Huckstadt was born in Mecklenburg, Germany in 1819. Herman married Louisa Sebastian in Germany. Louisa had emigrated from France. Herman and Louisa had 2 daughters and one son. Bertha was born 12 Oct 1844, Ulla born 4 Jan 1848 and Otto George Hartwick (Great-Grandfather Huckstadt) born 4 Jun 1851 in Krakow, Germany. A safe assumption would be that Bertha and Ulla were also born in Krakow. The Huckstadt family emigrated to America in 1866. They first settled in Iowa, then in 1867 they moved to Kansas. Herman died a year later, in 1868, in Flush, Kansas. Louisa died 27 Jun 1879, probably in Kansas. There is no information about the deaths of Bertha and Ulla, nor where they died.
Great-Grandfather Otto Huckstadt met and married Rosanna “Rosa” Charlotte Haid in Louisville, Kansas on 23 Sep 1877. Great-Grandmother Rosa was born 29 Mar 1860 in Flush, Kansas. Otto and Rosa had had 5 children: Herman George born 18 Sep 1878 in Louisville, Kansas, Louis Charles born 22 Feb 1880 in Louisville, Kansas, Charlotte “Lottie” Estelle (Grandmother Price) born 23 Jul 1881 in Louisville, Kansas, Bertha Ann born 22 May 1884 somewhere in Kansas and Ora Florence born 26 Oct 1898 in Shannon, Kansas. Great-Grandfather Huckstadt died on 11 Aug 1908 in Westmoreland, Kansas. Great-Grandmother Huckstadt died on 4 May 1944 in Garden City, Kansas. To my knowledge, the Huckstadts and their spouses were farmers.
Since Great-Grandmother Rosa Huckstadt’s maiden name was Haid it is only appropriate to chronicle the Haid family history. The Haid family also begins in Germany with Great-Great-Great-Grandfather Mathias Haid. He was born in 1804 in Bavaria, Germany----at least that is the way it is listed. Probably just Bavaria is more likely. Mathias married a woman whose maiden name was Frazier. Family records show only one son: John George (Great-Great- Grandfather Haid) born 8 Sep 1827 in Wittenburg, Germany. John emigrated to America in 1849, first landing in New York City with only 5 cents to his name. Somehow he traveled to Albany, New York and was hired for his first job--picking tomatoes. During the next 6 years he continued moving West with jobs in Rochester, Syracuse and Seneca, New York and Erie, Pennsylvania. From Erie he migrated to Michigan for 2 years, finally moving to Leavenworth, Kansas in 1857, where he worked on a farm for one summer. Here he met Charlotte Peck from Charlton, Lincolnshire, England. Charlotte was born 17 Jul 1838. She emigrated to America in 1857, settled in Illinois and moved to Leavenworth, Kansas in 1857. Although John was attracted to Charlotte, he left Leavenworth and bought 80 acres in Pottawattamie County, Kansas for a yoke of oxen in 1858. With the help of neighbors he built a house and improved the land and in 1859 returned to Leavenworth to marry Charlotte. The were married on 20 July 1859 in Leavenworth. They loaded their belongings onto a wagon and started for his farm. Unfortunately, a prairie fire totally destroyed his farm house, so they were without any shelter upon their arrival. Once again the neighbors helped them through this ordeal by providing temporary shelter while a new house was built.
John and Charlotte Haid had 8 children: Rosanna “Rosa” Charlotte (Great-Grandmother Huckstadt) born 29 Mar 1860 in Flush, Kansas, Harriet born 28 Aug 1862, Anna Matilda born 29 Dec 1863, Sarah abt 1864, Stephan born 12 Aug 1865, Henry born 12 Dec 1866, Herbert born 18 Feb 1869 and William Reginald born 22 Mar 1875. Except for Great-Grandmother Rosa there is no specific location cited for the birth of the other children. I believe it is safe to assume they were all born in Pottawattamie County.
Although Pottawattamie County was being settled, it was still a wild country. Taking crops to a mill for grinding was 80 miles away and several farmers went together for protection from Indian attacks. Indians would stop by the Haid farm asking for food. Great-Great-Grandfather Haid always accommodated the request, the best they could, to prevent attacks. During the Civil War in 1863 Bushwhackers pillaged the town of Leavenworth and Great-Great Grandfather Haid went with the Kansas militia to aid Leavenworth. This raid occurred just prior to “Price’s Raid”. This raid was led by Confederate General Sterling Price. My first thought was “uh oh” However, General Price was born in Virginia about 1805, so was not related as far as I can tell at this time---Whew! It would have been rather ironic if the two families had crossed swords during the Civil War. Great-Great-Grandfather Haid died 29 Jul 1908 in Wamengo, Kansas. Great- Great-Grandmother Haid died 1 Jul 1927, also in Wamengo, Kansas.
This chapter of Reflections has been like the Book of Deuteronomy in the Bible---a whole lot of begetting going on. Research cannot be said to be “final”, since there are still some weak branches, which definitely need more watering. I am sure there will be additions and corrections to the information presented in this chapter. Even so this research provides some insight as to our family legacy. While this is valuable information it does not tell us about occupations and stories that can be passed on to later generations. The stories about Great-Great-Grandfather Haid were made possible because Dad’s cousin had the foresight to ask questions of Great-Grandmother Rosa Huckstadt and then wrote a paper in high school. Maybe it was an assignment and not foresight, but why does not really matter, does it? The story is priceless! The following chapters in Reflections will be devoted to family stories I remember and experienced.